Thursday, June 16, 2011

Superman III Blu-Ray Review

Rated PG

Running Time: 2 Hours & 5 Minutes

Cast:
Christopher Reeve-Clark Kent/Superman
Margot Kidder-Lois Lane
Annette O'Toole-Lana Lang
Richard Pryor-August ‘Gus’ Gorman
Marc McClure-Jimmy Olsen
Jackie Cooper-Perry White
Robert Vaughn-Ross Webster
Annie Ross-Vera Webster
Pamela Stephenson-Lorelei Ambrosia
Gavan O'Herlihy-Brad Wilson
Paul Kaethler-Ricky Lang

Directed by Richard Lester

This guy tried to kill you and you're letting him go?!
Note: Part of the "Superman Motion Picture Anthology" Blu-Ray set.

It seems the third time’s not the charm for Superman as Christopher Reeve reprises his famous role in 1983’s “Superman III.” Although director Richard Lester received official credit for the production-troubled “Superman II,” the sequel only managed to live up to the heights of the original thanks to the efforts of ‘creative consultant’ Tom Mankiewicz and previous director Richard Donner, who had shot roughly three-quarters of the film before being unceremoniously fired by the producers, Alexander and his son, Ilya Salkind. With Donner and Mankiewicz out of the picture, the Salkinds finally had free rein to adapt their vision of a “Superman” film, which is a campy comedy that disrespects the source material. Apparently, Lester had not even heard of Superman when he replaced Donner because comic books were not allowed in his house when he was a child. Hiring someone who had no experience with the source material just really boggles the mind. The Salkinds were eager to cast comedian Richard Pryor (who passed away in 2005 at the age of 65) in the third film after he commented on The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson about how much he enjoyed “Superman II.” As Lester had directed a number of popular comedies, including the highly successful “The Three Musketeers” series for the Salkinds, it was believed that “Superman III” would be a sure-fire hit with its new tone. While it was a moderate box office success and had a few interesting ideas at work, “Superman III” is a dull entry in the series, so desperate in its attempts at comedy that it loses the grandiose quality that made the previous films so good to begin with. It also does not help that all the characters are depicted as total morons but despite all these problems, “Superman III” remains surprisingly watchable thanks to the presence of Christopher Reeve. 

August ‘Gus’ Gorman (Richard Pryor) has his unemployment benefits terminated but discovers his skill for computer programming after seeing an advertisement on the back of a matchbox (Call 123-456-789?). Gorman manages to land a job at Webscoe Industries, owned by wealthy industrialist Ross Webster (Robert Vaughn). Meanwhile, mild-mannered reporter Clark Kent (Christopher Reeve) arrives at The Daily Planet and informs editor-in-chief Perry White (Jackie Cooper) of his plans of visiting his hometown, Smallville, for a high-school reunion and writing an article about how ‘the typical small town has changed in the last fifteen years!’ White gives him the okay while Lois Lane (Margot Kidder) is going on vacation in Bermuda. On route to Smallville with Jimmy Olsen (Marc McClure) tagging on, Clark is forced to change into Superman when a nearby chemical plant catches on fire. Back at Webscoe, Gorman puts his hacking skills to the test by embezzling money from the company, bringing him to the attention of Webster, who realizes Gorman’s potential and decides to use him in his shady schemes to rule the financial world. At Smallville, Clark is reunited with his childhood friend, Lana Lang (Annette O'Toole), a recently divorced mother with a son named Ricky (Paul Kaethler). Webster tasks Gorman with hacking into the weather satellite ‘Vulcan’ to destroy Columbia’s coffee crop as punishment for refusing to do business with him but Superman arrives to save the day. Determined to get rid of the Man of Steel, Webster has Gorman discover the chemical composition of kryptonite in order to synthesize it. Gorman, disguised as an army officer, presents the kryptonite to Superman as a gift at Ricky’s birthday party but to his dismay, it has no ill effect on him. However, it does have an effect as the synthetic kryptonite causes a personality change in Superman, who begins to shirk his responsibilities and commits petty acts of vandalism around the world. With Superman out of the way, Webster puts the next phase of his plan in motion by monopolizing the world’s oil supply, with a reluctant Gorman in tow. 

It’s a bad sign when the film opens to an unfunny slapstick sequence during the hard-to-read opening credits. The original script by Ilya Salkind included Mr. Mxyzptlk, a father-daughter relationship between Brainiac and Supergirl, and a romance between her and Superman, which is kind-of creepy considering the two were cousins in the comics. It just goes to show you how much respect the Salknds had for the source material. At least Warner Brothers wisely rejected it but it’s not like what we got was any better. While comedy played a part in the previous films, it was restrained and most importantly, funny. “Superman III” comes across as desperate in its attempts that most of the jokes either fall flat or end up annoying. One bit had Gorman causing all sorts of mayhem when he hacks into the Vulcan weather satellite in a drunken stupor, which starts off somewhat funny when ATM’s start spitting out money or traffic signs going haywire but when the figures on the walk, don’t-walk sign begin to animate and fight each other, you just know the filmmakers were on some sort of drugs! Maybe they were drunk like Gorman. The film also has a dated tone with its ‘gee-whiz’ attitude with computers as characters repeatedly speak of their amazement with this new technology and its potential to do everything. An interesting piece of trivia: when Gorman inputs two bilateral coordinates in a program, the display is just a series of empty print statements so in reality, the program does absolutely nothing. Characters often behave like total morons. I find it hard to believe that a bumbling dolt like Gorman can program and hack with such skill, and he’s unable to even explain how he manages to do it. Even Superman is not immune as he displays no suspicion at all when he is handed a chunk of rock that resembles kryptonite. 

“Superman III” is not a total loss as the romance between Clark and Lana does end up being sweet and adorable, although it’s promptly dropped in the second hour. Perhaps the film’s most memorable moment is the junkyard battle between Evil Superman and Clark Kent. I’ll admit Lester did do a good job with Evil Superman, with his unkempt appearance and costume’s darker color scheme. This battle brings up a number of questions. Are the two really fighting or is it all in Superman’s mind? Unfortunately, Evil Superman’s ‘destructive’ acts end up being a lost opportunity. Apparently, bad involves blowing out the Olympic torch, straightening the Leaning Tower of Pisa, causing an oil spill in the middle of the Atlantic (okay, that is bad), and getting drunk while flicking peanuts at the windows. He also has a one-night stand with Webster’s blond bimbo girlfriend, Lorelei Ambrosia (Pamela Stephenson). The film ends with Superman facing a sentient computer (Skynet?) of all things. Hell, Webster even battles Superman through an Atari video game and his sister Vera (Annie Ross) is transformed into a Borg knock-off. Plenty of loud explosions ensue and we are left scratching our heads, wondering just what the heck we watched. Adding to the film’s forgettable nature is Ken Thorne’s score, which lacks the epic power and volume of the previous films with John Williams iconic theme rarely used. 

Despite its age, the special effects hold up rather well, although the Salkinds concern with keeping it within budget is apparent in how little screen-time Superman receives when compared to the boorish antics of Gorman. Christopher Reeve remains as one of the few shining bright spots in this film and one of the best scenes is when he saves an unconscious Ricky before he meets a gory end at the hands of a threshing machine. Ricky wakes up and asks, ‘Superman?’ and Reeve then gives his winning smile and replies, ‘That’s me!’ He also does an excellent job portraying his evil self. Annette O'Toole is another bright spot, capturing the small-town sweetness and charm of Lana Lang and has some good chemistry with Reeve, although nothing on the level between him and Kidder. Ironically, O’Toole would go on to play Superman’s adopted mother, Martha Kent, on the television series “Smallville.” Margot Kidder only appears in what amounts to a glorified cameo as punishment for publicly criticizing the Salkinds for their treatment of Donner, although the producers deny this on the Blu-Ray’s audio commentary. The less said about Richard Pryor, the better. While he’s a highly regarded comedian, here he’s just annoying to the point where I wish Superman would just crush his skull and be done with it. I’ll admit that some of the comedy produced a chuckle but that’s about it. Robert Vaughn makes for a poor substitute for Gene Hackman with his uninspired Ross Webster. He comes off as an overly cartoonish James Bond villain, complete with his own secret lair! 

“Superman III” arrives for the first time on Blu-Ray as part of the “Superman Motion Picture Anthology” box set. I didn’t expect the film to look amazing given its less-than favorable reaction but the picture quality makes it look like it was shot yesterday! Blacks are deep and inky, and textures are highly defined from Evil Superman’s five-o-clock shadow to the circuit boards on Gorman’s ridiculous super-computer. Audio is excellent as well and is at its most dynamic during the climax as all manner of explosions go off. Dialogue and sound effects has a bit of a dated feel like the previous films in the set but other than that, there are no complaints. Special features are a bit light compared to “Superman” and “Superman II” and included is an audio commentary with producers Ilya Salkind and Pierre Spengler, a 50-minute making-of featurette, eleven deleted scenes and a theatrical trailer, all presented in standard definition. 

Released on June 17, 1983, “Superman III” received largely negative reviews and currently has a 24% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics noted that ‘when not overusing sight gags, slapstick, and Richard Pryor, [the film] resorts to plot points rehashed from the previous Superman flicks.’ With an estimated production budget of $39 million, the film was a moderate box office success with a domestic total of $60 million, though it was a far cry from the $100 million grosses of the previous films. Reeve wasn’t particularly fond of Lester’s penchant for comedy and remarked that ‘[He] was always looking for a gag—sometimes to the point where the gags involving Richard Pryor went over the top. I mean, I didn't think that his going off the top of a building, on skis with a pink tablecloth around his shoulders, was particularly funny.’ Due to the negative reaction to the film, Reeve and the producers felt that the “Superman” films had run their course and after the release of “Supergirl” in 1984 (which also received negative reviews and was a box office bomb), the Salkinds sold the rights to the franchise to Golan & Globus of Cannon Films four years later. While “Superman III” remains watchable, the film’s overreliance on gags and slapstick ends up grating and is a slap in the face to both the fans and the source material. Of course, it’s infinitely better to what came after…but that is a story best left for another day.

Final Rating: 2.5 out of 5

“You're a genius. You've invented a machine that can find anybody's weak spot. Congratulations, old buddy. You'll go down in history as the man who killed Superman!”