Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Escape from the Planet of the Apes Blu-Ray Review

Rated G

Running Time: 1 Hour & 37 Minutes

Cast:
Roddy McDowall-Dr. Cornelius
Kim Hunter-Dr. Zira
Sal Mineo-Dr. Milo
Natalie Trundy-Dr. Stephanie Branton
Bradford Dillman-Dr. Lewis Dixon
Eric Braeden-Dr. Otto Hasslein
Ricardo Montalban-Señor Armando
William Windom-President of the United States

Directed by Don Taylor

Roddy McDowall and Kim Hunter make for an endearing and sympathetic couple in "Escape from the Planet of the Apes."
Note: Part of the "Planet of the Apes" 40-Year Evolution Blu-Ray Collection.

Despite killing off everyone as it was intended to be the last of the series, “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” performed solidly at the domestic box office despite tepid reviews, convincing 20th Century Fox to green-light another sequel. A simple telegram was reportedly sent to writer Paul Dehn in England: ‘APES LIVE! SEQUEL REQUIRED!’ For the third film, much of the cast and crew had already departed with the exception of producer Arthur P. Jacobs, art director William Creber, Academy Award winning makeup artist John Chambers, and cast members Roddy McDowall and Kim Hunter. As the rule of diminishing returns in cinema dictates, the third part in a franchise is almost always the worst but 1971’s “Escape from the Planet of the Apes” defies this and proves the third time’s the charm. Dehn turns the original concept on its head, crafting a sequel that’s more character driven and offers up philosophical musings as strong and relevant as the first film. “Escape from the Planet of the Apes” is by far the best of the sequels as it is the one that successfully captures what made the first film such a classic piece of science-fiction story-telling to begin with. 

Two years have passed since astronauts George Taylor and John Brent have disappeared in space, their whereabouts unknown. Military personnel are scrambled when a strange spaceship is found floating off the coast of Los Angeles. When the three astronauts emerge from the wreckage and take off their helmets, everyone is shocked to discover that they are apes! Transported to a secluded area in the Los Angeles Zoo, the apes are put under the observation of two scientists, Stephanie Branton (Natalie Trundy) and Lewis Dixon (Bradford Dillman), who perform a series of simple tests on the female ape. However, she shocks them by beginning to talk, inadvertently revealing that they have the power of speech. We learn that the apes are none other than Cornelius (Roddy McDowall), Zira (Kim Hunter), and Dr. Milo (Sal Mineo). Correctly deducing that they have arrived in Earth’s past (specifically 1973), Milo argues that it is best for them to remain silent for the time being but he is accidentally killed when an agitated gorilla grabs him by the neck. A Presidential Commission is formed where Cornelius and Zira are questioned before the public. They reveal that Dr. Milo salvaged and repaired Taylor’s spaceship and used it to travel back to Earth’s past. With their friendly and out-going nature, the two apes are welcomed as guests and quickly become worldwide celebrities. Zira reveals she is pregnant, much to the joy of Cornelius. However, Science Advisor to the President Dr. Otto Hasslein (Eric Braeden) is suspicious and uses every trick to discover what the apes know about the future of humanity. Learning that man will one day regress to a primal state to be dominated by simians and that the Earth will be destroyed in a cataclysmic explosion in 3955, Hasslein takes matters into his hands to change the future by plotting the deaths of Cornelius and Zira to prevent the birth of their offspring. 

I was surprised at how much I enjoyed “Escape from the Planet of the Apes,” with its sympathetic main characters and a script that at times rivals that of the original film. This second sequel intelligently reverses the concept of the first film, with the apes arriving at the height of man’s power in 1973. As such, certain scenes mirror the original, such as the initial disbelief that the apes are intelligent and the interrogation by the Presidential Commission. Where it begins to differ is the humans’ treatment of the apes as Cornelius and Zira quickly become celebrities, capturing the hearts and minds of the public. The first half is quite humorous, which might seem out of place given the serious nature of the previous two films. The ape couple is helped by Stephanie and Lewis as they settle into this new world but their fame is short-lived. Dr. Otto Hasslein represents humanity’s fear of the unknown and upon learning of the terrible fate that will befall his race he decides to attempt to change the future. The central question the film asks is whether knowledge of the future gives you the right to change it. There’s an interesting exchange between the U.S. President (William Windom) and Hasslein, where they discuss the implications of such knowledge. An analogy is made where if we were to encounter Adolf Hitler as an infant. Knowing the man he will become, would it be right to kill him right then and there? The answers aren’t so simple. This was actually explored in an episode of the 2002 revival of “The Twilight Zone.” Man’s hypocrisy is also revealed when Zira, under the effects of a truth serum, admits that she experimented on humans in the future, but Hasslein is taken aback despite the fact that they’ve done the same to animals. While the previous installments contained action, it was low-key but this film is completely character driven and we really sympathize for the ape couple’s plight. What’s ironic is that Hasslein failed to change the future but instead sealed it, all because he was afraid and driven by misguided intentions. 

Performances are strong as Roddy McDowall and Kim Hunter manage to overcome the restrictive makeup to create an endearing couple in Cornelius and Zira. Their fish-out-of-water experiences of the human world generate quite a few laughs but they also capture that sense of desperation and isolation when faced with so much hostility. Natalie Trundy and Bradford Dillman is essentially a human mirror of the apes’ roles in the original film, almost immediately accepting them as friends. Eric Braeden is very effective as Dr. Otto Hasslein, exuding a cold logic in a selfish bid to save his race by killing three innocents. I appreciated that the film allows us to understand where he is coming from but also condemns his actions. Ricardo Montalbán (Khan from “Star Trek II”) also appears but his role is relatively small. 

Arriving on Blu-Ray as a separate release or part of the 40-Year Evolution box-set, “Escape from the Planet of the Apes” looks the sharpest by far with strong depth to shadows and a pleasing natural color palette to textures. While it won’t win any awards, audio is fine, driven more by dialogue compared to the previous films but Jerry Goldsmith’s score can be unusually loud. Special features are disappointingly lacking again with only a brief, sixteen-minute featurette on the making of the film. 

“Escape from the Planet of the Apes” was released on May 21, 1971 to positive reviews with a current score of 78% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics found it ‘more character-driven than the previous films, and more touching as a result.’ Requiring little to no elaborate sets or effects, the production budget was low at $2.5 million but it ended up grossing only $12 million, or approximately $67 million when adjusted for inflation, a far cry from the previous installments. One of the reasons given by producer Arthur P. Jacobs was that since it was a more intimate picture, the spectacle audiences were expecting was missing. Still, as the ending was deliberately left open-ended, another sequel would follow a year later, with continuing diminished financial returns and an increasingly reduced production budget. “Escape from the Planet of the Apes” lacks the shocking impact of the original but it does recall what it did right and follows in its footsteps, resulting in a sequel that feels surprisingly fresh both thematically and emotionally.

Final Rating: 4 out of 5

“I do know this: one of the reasons for man's original downfall was your peculiar habit of murdering one another! Man destroys man. Apes do not destroy apes!”