Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Beneath the Planet of the Apes Blu-Ray Review

Rated G

Running Time: 1 Hour & 35 Minutes

Cast:
James Franciscus-John Brent
Charlton Heston-Colonel George Taylor
David Watson-Dr. Cornelius
Kim Hunter-Dr. Zira
Maurice Evans-Dr. Zaius (Minister of Science)
Linda Harrison-Nova
James Gregory-General Ursus
Paul Richards-Mendez XXVI
Victor Buono-Adiposo
Don Pedro Colley-Ongaro
Jeff Corey-Caspay
Natalie Trundy-Albina
Gregory Sierra-Verger

Directed by Ted Post

Where's Charlton Heston when you need him?
Note: Part of the "Planet of the Apes" 40-Year Evolution Blu-Ray Collection.

With “Planet of the Apes” becoming a surprise critical and commercial success in early 1968, 20th Century Fox wasted no time green-lighting a sequel. However, pre-production was hampered by script issues as the writers had trouble creating a story that could top the original’s shocking ending. Rod Serling‘s (who co-wrote the first film with Michael Wilson) initial idea was to have Taylor and Nova discover the remnants of a human city in a dark, unexplored area of the ape planet. Taylor would then battle with the apes that followed him until a second spaceship arrives from the past to save him. Despite given the opportunity to return to his own time, Taylor decides to stay and attempt to rebuild human civilization. Producer Mort Abrahams found the idea lacked a memorable ending on par with the original and felt that the sequel’s plot should be built around that final scene. Serling supplied two alternate scenarios but both of them were rejected. Pierre Boulle, the writer for the novel on which the first film was based on, tried his hand at the script which saw Taylor and Nova re-educating a group of primitive humans in the Forbidden Zone over the course of many years and eventually defeating the apes, reducing them to a more primal state. This treatment was dubbed “Planet of the Men” but while the producers accepted it, very little of the ideas contained within made it into what became “Beneath the Planet of the Apes.” Also problematic was that Charlton Heston flatly refused to return for the sequel but relented on the condition that his character is killed off in an ending that would prevent anymore follow-ups to be made. New director Ted Post disliked the script due to the unhopeful and pessimistic tone but writer Paul Dehn did as the producers ordered. With all these behind-the-scenes issues, I’m not surprised that “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” didn’t turn out as well as everyone hoped as it seemed no one was really satisfied with the project. The pacing is choppy and too much was basically a rehash but the sequel remains watchable thanks to a few intriguing ideas and its logical continuation of the original’s social themes. 

Picking up immediately after the events of “Planet of the Apes,” astronaut George Taylor (Charlton Heston) and his mute lover, Nova (Linda Harrison), have disappeared after discovering the terrible secret of the Forbidden Zone. Another spaceship crash-lands on the planet, sent from Earth on a search-and-rescue mission for Taylor and his crew. The sole survivor is John Brent (James Franciscus), who discovers that the year is 3955. He encounters Nova riding alone on horseback and finds Taylor’s dog-tags around her neck. Through a flashback, it is revealed that Taylor encountered strange phenomena such as great walls of fire, lightning strikes, and an earthquake. Investigating, he falls through what appears to be a solid cliff wall. Determined to find Taylor, Brent rides with Nova to the ape’s city and shockingly discovers the simian civilization. He overhears a gorilla named General Ursus (James Gregory) rallying the apes to invade and conquer the Forbidden Zone due to several scout disappearances. The orangutans and chimpanzees, although reluctant, have no choice but to agree. Brent is wounded by a gorilla soldier and Nova brings him to the home of doctors Cornelius (David Watson) and Zira (Kim Hunter). They tell him what they know of Taylor’s whereabouts but Brent and Nova are captured to be used as target practice. Zira helps them escape and the two find themselves in the underground ruins of New York City. Brent and Nova make a shocking discovery: a group of humans have survived but they now suffer grotesque mutations due to prolonged exposure to radiation. These mutants wield powerful telepathic abilities and worship a doomsday device, the ΑΩ bomb, and are determined to use it once the apes invade, leading to catastrophic consequences. 

To no one’s surprise, “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” does not live up to the heights set by the original and is little more than a poorly paced rehash until the last act. The first half is uninspired, with another astronaut finding himself stranded on the ape planet. Played by Heston stand-in James Franciscus, Brent goes through the motions with the discovery of intelligent simians and subsequently escapes from his gorilla captors but all of it is rushed. Once Brent and Nova find themselves underground, the film slows down considerably and director Post cannot seem to get the pacing right as it’s often too erratic. Fortunately, the sequel does logically follow and expand upon the themes from the first film. This time it’s the inevitability of war and whether human or ape, both sides are capable of destruction but the latter is more hypocritical because the gorillas believe what they are doing is right, even though they have unknowingly begun to walk the path that led to the annihilation of humanity. This recalls the religiously sanctioned military campaigns known as the Crusades which dominated much of the eleventh, twelfth, and thirteenth centuries. The goal was to restore Christian control of the Holy Land from the Muslims but it was simply driven by racial and religious intolerances. There’s also an unsubtle reference to the growing discontent among Americans about the Vietnam War with a group of young chimpanzees leading a peaceful protest. However, the sequel takes a strange turn once it introduces the telepathic mutants who worship an atomic bomb, a symbol of man’s destructive capabilities. Those of you who’ve played Bethesda’s open-world video game “Fallout 3” may recall a similar cult called the ‘Church of the Children of Atom.’ I found this to be an intriguing addition but it’s left unexplored due to the short running time. In fact, this is the major failing of “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” as the final script is essentially a patch-work of ideas that aren’t given sufficient time to be explored in more detail. Still, the sequel remains watchable but that’s as far as my praise goes. 

Reinforcing my overall feelings, the acting is adequate. Charlton Heston, Linda Harrison, Maurice Evans, and Kim Hunter reprise their respective roles, lending the film a sense of legitimacy but Roddy McDowall was unable to return as he was directing “The Devil’s Widow” in Scotland at the time. David Watson replaces him but it’s so seamless viewers probably won’t notice the switch. The only newcomer is James Franciscus who simply apes Heston and is a little more than a fill-in until the genuine article shows up in the last fifteen or so minutes. The action packs a bit more of a punch this time around, ending with a rather bloody (at the time) shootout but it won’t excite modern audiences. 

Released as separate and part of the ’40-Year Evolution’ box set, “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” looks solid, the barren desert and vegetation nicely detailed but the extra resolution reveals some not-quite-seamless matte effects. Like its predecessor, the image betrays the film’s age and some scenes suffer from heavy grain but it’s rare. Audio is a mixed bag as sometimes the dialogue sounds too low and the effects ear-piercingly loud. Still, this is the best the film is ever going to sound so I shouldn’t complain. Supplements are lacking but there’s a decent twenty-two minute featurette on the making of the sequel and the troubled production it faced. 

Released on May 27, 1970, “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” received a mixed reception from critics and fans of the first film and it currently has a score of 41% on Rotten Tomatoes. Reactions from the cast and crew were universally negative with the exception of Maurice Evans. With a reduced production budget of $3 million, the sequel grossed a solid $19 million or the approximate equivalent of $110 million when adjusted for inflation. While it’s less than the original, the crew expected this since it was a sequel and it earned enough for 20th Century Fox to green-light another follow-up despite the finality of the ending. “Beneath the Planet of the Apes” is a watchable entry in the series but its behind-the scenes troubles with the script, the choppy pacing and a rehashed first half led to an inferior film. Director Ted Post made the best of an impossible situation so I’m glad that the final result turned out as well as it could be.

Final Rating: 3 out of 5

“I'll tell you one thing that every good soldier knows! The only thing that counts in the end is power! Naked merciless force!”