Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Sinister Review

Rated R (Disturbing Violent Images and Some Terror)

Running Time: 1 Hour & 50 Minutes

Cast-
Ethan Hawke-Ellison Oswalt
Juliet Rylance-Tracy Oswalt
Michael Hall D'Addario-Trevor Oswalt
Clare Foley-Ashley Oswalt
James Ransone-Deputy
Fred Dalton Thompson-Sheriff
Vincent D'Onofrio-Professor Jonas
Nicholas King-Bughuul/Mr. Boogie

Directed by Scott Derrickson

Ethan Hawke discovers some amateur porn in the attic of his new house
Has Hollywood lost the ability to scare us? The last two weeks of August saw the release of "The Apparition" and "The Possession" but the former flopped (massively I must say) in the scares department and couldn't even muster some cheap thrills while the latter simply ripped-off of "The Exorcist," only it was dumbed down for the PG-13 crowd. The number of horror films that have managed to strike a chord with me over the last twenty or so years are small but now you can add "Sinister" into the mix. Directed by Scott Derrickson and produced by Jason Blum (whose previous credits include 2009's "Paranormal Activity" and 2011's "Insidious"), the film mixes the serial killer, found-footage, and haunted house subgenres to create something that actually fills you with a sense of dread and unease despite treading some well-worn territory. I have to admit that the experience of watching "Sinister" left me drained by the time the end credits rolled due to the intense atmosphere that Derrickson has created. It serves as further proof that horror isn't just about creating a sense of revulsion with blood and guts but on reducing the audience to their baser instincts, to make them feel genuinely afraid as they sit inside of a darkened theater. "Sinister" does not rewrite the rules of its genre and suffers from some truly hackneyed moments but it's a surprisingly effective horror film that manages to feel fresh thanks to its disturbing visuals and chilling sound design. 

After becoming a household name with the release of his book Kentucky Blood, true-crime novelist Ellison Oswalt (Ethan Hawke) has been struggling for the past ten years to replicate that same success but to no avail. For his latest novel, Ellison moves his entire family to a small town where a young girl disappeared under mysterious circumstances after her entire family was murdered by hanging. Unbeknownst to his wife Tracy (Juliet Rylance), the house that her husband brought is the same house where the murders took place. Stopping by for an impromptu visit, the local sheriff (Fred Dalton Thompson) expresses his dislike of a fame-hungry writer second-guessing his department's investigation. Soon after he moves in, Ellison discovers a box containing reels of Super 8 film in the attic. Each film begins as an innocent home movie of a family gathering before suddenly cutting to them being brutally murdered in various ways. One of the reels proves to be especially disturbing as he sees a dark figure with a demonic face come into view. Believing he's stumbled upon his own version of In Cold Blood, Ellison becomes obsessed with solving the murders and enlists the help of a star-struck deputy (James Ransone). Strange occurrences begin to haunt the house and it soon becomes clear that Ellison and his family are in terrible danger the longer they stay. 

To horror veterans, much of what happens in "Sinister" won't be a total surprise but what puts it a cut above the rest is Derrickson's skillful use of horrific imagery, opening with grainy Super 8 footage of a family being hung from a tree and setting the tone for the rest of the film. Although there's a surprising amount of restraint with the gore, there is one key scene that invokes a sense of morbid voyeurism that's almost Hitchcock-like. During one late-night viewing session, Ellison watches as the killer prepares to slit his victim's throats (each one bound to their beds) but it immediately cuts to our haggard protagonist weakly closing his eyes while the gruesome bloodshed happening before him is reflected in his eyeglasses. Despite the effect these films have on him, he continues to watch and so do we, tapping into our fascination with evil. Derrickson also replicates the rough editing of Super 8 within the film to ratchet up the tension. A creepy score from Christopher Young is overlaid with each flickering reel, adding to its already tense atmosphere with a faint child-like chanting and other deeply unsettling sounds, blurring the lines between music and sound design. 

The script from C. Robert Cargill does not feel like a supernatural tale, at least not at first as the footage that Ellison watches is filmed as if a serial killer was both documenting and admiring his own work. This grounds "Sinister," allowing the audience to buy into its more ridiculous aspects as it slowly unveils an interesting backstory about an obscure Pagan entity known as 'Bughuul.' While the marital drama is well-done, some of the dialogue can get downright cringe worthy, such as a heated exchange where our beleaguered hero exclaims to his wife that this could be his version of In Cold Blood. The director also relies on jump scares a little too much, with Ellison wandering around his house at night yet he never turns on the lights for some inexplicable reason. The fact that his son Trevor (Michael Hall D'Addario) sleepwalks and has night terrors makes carrying a butcher knife rather head-scratching. However, we forgive this because the rest of "Sinister" is so well-made due to its foreboding, slow-burn atmosphere. This is a film that rewards patience and might even leave you sleeping with one eye open. 

"Sinister" is a one-man show, with Ethan Hawke giving a convincing performance as a true-crime novelist who initially wants to solve the murders to recapture his former glory but it soon becomes less about the book and more on his insatiable need to know what happened to these families. Hawke's Ellison Oswalt is arrogant and selfish yet he remains a sympathetic character, his research taking its toll on his mental health and marriage as the film wears on. Although underwritten, Juliet Rylance is fine as Ellison's long-suffering wife while James Ransone provides some much needed levity as an eccentric deputy sheriff. Vincent D'Onofrio also pops up, literally phoning it in through Skype. Premiering back in March as a 'secret' screening during the South by Southwest (SXSW) Festival, 

"Sinister" will be released on October 12, 2012 and has received largely positive reviews so far with 76% on Rotten Tomatoes. I attended an advance screening this past Monday (which was packed and many people were turned away) and the response was somewhat mixed. Thankfully, the audience wasn't as rowdy given their usual penchant to provide their own audio commentary. "Sinister" should do well at the box office this weekend thanks to its effective marketing campaign despite three other releases competing but it won't become the breakout success it hopes to be as "Paranormal Activity 4" is opening a week later. Going in with absolutely no expectations, "Sinister" really took me by surprise and while it's hardly original, this is a horror film that succeeds in what a horror film should do: scaring the pants off its audience.

Final Rating: 4 out of 5

"Get the kids. Pack the car. We have to leave here now!"